Transgenderism and False Equivalence Arguments
URL: https://apnews.com/article/arkansas-state-government-south-dakota-tennessee-utah-mississippi-bb6bc7f6e7d5d733c081b2b87e958171?utm_source=homepage&utm_medium=TopNews&utm_campaign=position_06
Curious Image huh. Definitely != to me.
Its one thing to treat people with respect and dignity regardless of the unknown sexual preference.
Its another thing to pretend sexual preference gets one special treatment.
“Oh your Gay? I’ll defer to what you think matters!”
“Oh your Straight? I don’t have to listen to you or pretend your opinion matters!”
If that be the measure of ones thinking, what one mistakes for thinking is pavlovian response to specific stimuli.
I’ve bumped into this article now in several forms and this one from the Associated Press is the most clarifying use of false equivalence I’ve seen in biased write ups.
Clearly the AP is PRO genital mutilation and anti-psychiatry.
The article starts out with a transgender with the last name Herzig who spoke out in front of Arkansas legislature on why they Should NOT deny hormone blockers and treatments for minors. You’ve probably seen the video on twitter or youtube where the girlish looking boy sits there and pretends her biggest issue is a Lack of Empathy.
“Herzig, who is transgender, spoke out against the legislation and told the panel that one of the biggest obstacles trans people face is a lack of empathy. Only a few minutes later, a Republican lawmaker asked her an inappropriate question about her genitalia.” Quoted from article.
If you missed it you can catch it here:
https://sg001-harmony.sliq.net/00284/Harmony/en/PowerBrowser/PowerBrowserV2/20230213/-1/26533?viewMode=1#agenda_
“The exchange, which was livestreamed on the Legislature’s website and has since been widely shared on social media, is an example of the type of demeaning questions and rhetoric that transgender people meet when they show up to statehouses to testify against new bills targeting their rights.
…
Bans on gender-affirming care for minors have already been enacted this year in South Dakota and Utah, and Republican governors in Tennessee and Mississippi are expected to sign similar bans into law. Arkansas and Alabama have bans that were temporarily blocked by federal judges.”
From the above quote, Federal Judges can’t block INTRA-state legislation. They can only block INTRA-state legislation. They, the fed gov, have no jurisdiction WITHIN the states borders. Whatever is happening has to Cross from one state into the next for the fed gov to involve itself in the boondoggle.
The next bit from the article reads:
“The push has included efforts in some states to restrict gender-affirming care for adults and proposed bans on drag shows that opponents have warned would also discriminate against transgender people.
Herzig came to the state Capitol to testify against a bill attempting to reinstate Arkansas’ ban on gender-affirming care for minors by making it easier to file malpractice lawsuits against providers. In her testimony, Herzig talked about working with transgender patients who are on hormone replacement therapy.”
Nowhere does the bill restrict care for ADULTS, it restricts CARE FOR MINORS! So they restate the problem INCORRECTLY, and pretend its all the same single thing.
Herzig testifies Against a bill that would make it easier to file malpractice suits against Providers… so that simple statement makes it have nothing to do with preventing transgender treatments to Minors but is instead against making it easier for transgenders who wake/woke up and feel betrayed to Sue their providers.
Even if she was there pushing for it to be OK for providers to provide transgender care for Minors, she would be against making it easy to sue for malpractice after one wakes up to the DUPING.
One might ask how does one Dupe themselves into believing this or that about themselves and then act on someone elses words who was the one pushing them to do what that one pushing won’t do themselves.
Herzig goes on to use wording that presents her argument as a LIE. See here:
““Bills like SB199 are designed to hinder, not help, Arkansans by creating barriers to evidence-driven health care they deserve under the guise of helping the young and innocent,” she said, later saying a vote for the bill was “unpatriotic, and casts doubts on our own health and research institutions who have worked through health care fields to improve the lives of Americans.””
The whole statement is idiotic, evidence-driven, under the guise, etc. Actually the bill is there to help transgenders who realize they made a mistake at the reinforced urging of their providers and who want redress for having been to stupid to Not destroy their own organism in the process of “finding themselves”.
Whats evidence driven are the now decade on consequences of the transitioned who have realized finally what they did to themselves and want redress, and the transgender whippits at the beginning of this process are just providing fodder for preventing that correction.
The fact she even says “under the guise” which means its presented as being helping the young and innocent but perhaps not the type of HELP they actually Need. If that statement was corrected for objective comprehension it would read:
“Bills like SB199 are designed to hinder, not help, Arkansans by creating barriers to evidence-driven health care by checking the transgender self mutilation movement with objective healthcare facts they deserve to know and understand under the guise of to help the young and innocent,"
Of course she then follows up her wayward wandering commentary with this false equivalence.
““unpatriotic, and casts doubts on our own health and research institutions who have worked through health care fields to improve the lives of Americans.”””
The only Doubts cast on health and research institutions is what actual goal they have at heart where they then go about trying to convince an ever larger majority of individuals that they were born into the Wrong body. As for patriotic or unpatriotic, it would have to be reduced to the objective reality produced for the nation such inhabits eh? Is it patriotic to have a bunch of men dressed as women and pretending they’re furries along with women dressed as men who portray their version of toxic masculinity which makes the total crowd unable to do anything but focus on their pronouns and if someone else has insulted them so they can refuse to tolerate anyone ELSES views but their own? If so maybe its unpatriotic, but to my own objective understanding where MEN are MEN and WOMEN are WOMEN, and both know and understand their attributes and how to best Make things Work, then I’ll call the transgender movement unpatriotic.
Patriotic is Standing Against the false equivalence and random arbitrary arguments that always seek to put the objective into the inane and pretend thats where reality resides.
Has a single one of these transgenders wondered why they feel like they do about themselves? or Why Nature saw fit to seed them into an iteration of form that doesn’t match up with their mentality regarding sex? Do they think Nature, the very thing that gave them their iteration of form, doesn’t know what its Doing?
Frankly I’m with McKee.
“McKee did not respond to an email or phone call, but defended his question in a written statement.
“As a father of 4 daughters, I will do everything in my power to protect my children and the children of Arkansas, especially from the woke mob who intend to push their agenda and beliefs down our throats and destroy our families,” McKee’s statement said.”
Course that AP article followed that paragraph with this assertion:
“The idea of protecting children by withholding medical care is undermined by health experts, who have said minors with gender dysphoria who do not receive appropriate care face dramatically increased risk of suicide and serious depression.”
You know how this was handled for the years preceeding the pioneering work of genital swapping in plastic surgery? Psychology/psychiatry. It might have messed up their minds, but their Minds could be fixed down the Road.
Now they pretend that removing a penis and adding a vagina or removing a vagina and adding a penis somehow does the one whose mentally having these thoughts and feelings, solves those thoughts and feelings? Hell even when psychiatry prescribed pills for depression the best they could do with Lithium was MUTE the emotional responses. Now they want to pretend “gender affirming” plastic surgery is somehow FIXING a problem that is Mental in its Roots.
I’d add, What do you think a gender transitioned person experiences once they realize they’ve ruined their sexuality permanently? You think they maybe feel depressed and suicidal about the consequences of their choices? or do you think they sit there and calculate who to sue to get paid for their own self mutilation? I have no idea frankly because I don’t tend to put accountability for MY choices on anyone but Myself.
But the article goes on and now its about Avery who is Jacksons son who wants to play in WOMENS sports as a transgender, alot like that clown LIA Thomas.
The article notes:
“McKee’s questions were similar in tone to those posed to Debi Jackson’s teen Avery, who is transgender and nonbinary, when they testified before Missouri legislators last year about a proposal to ban trans girls and women from participating on sports teams matching their gender identity.
During the hearing, a lawmaker asked Avery if they were “gonna go through the procedure.” Since that exchange, Jackson said Avery hasn’t wanted to testify again before the Legislature.
“It’s this same idea that in any of these discussions about trans people just being treated with basic dignity and respect, legislators want to reduce them to one body part,” Jackson said. “They miss the entirety of the human being sitting in front of them having a conversation.””
How convenient that the proponents of transgenderism keep the discussion at ideals as opposed to objective implementation and then Get offended when asked about the objective implementation. THEY brought up that they don’t want their Natural Sex Organ and want to Swap with a sterile opposite sex organ, but then when asked their status they balk and pretend “oh thats private”. Well, No its not, you’re sitting in a legislative review in PUBLIC calling out that you are this individual logically but when asked about objective aspects of the same they crumble.
Nevermind the false equivalence. This BOY who wants to be a GIRL to compete in GIRLS sports, likely so he can finally win, is what ats issue. Pretending that its only about a discussion wherein the transgender is treated with dignity and respect has nothing to do with if boys who cut off their penis’s should then participate in girls sports and be in girls locker rooms. And the answer is No they Shouldn’t.
If they want to have a decent conversation with dignity and respect then they should Approach the conversation in such a way. They shouldn’t sit there and pretend they should have all these concensions Cuz Tolerance, while they are ridiculously intolerant of the status quo being heterosexuality.
The minute they turn to false equivalence to push their agenda item the conversation should be kept objective and the facts be pointed out that, a dickless man does not a woman make, and a vaginaless woman does not a man make. Whats been made is a Eunuch and as such a new class of competition has to be defined for they who are so unhappy with what NATURE gave them that they self mutilate and no longer belong to MEN OR WOMEN but are now a 3rd THING APART from what exists in NATURE OBJECTIVELY.
Thus a new category for Transgenders has to be stood up and they who do the plastic surgeries are admited to that category for competition.
Now what happens when this is called out, is the transgenders get bent. Because its not About Fair, its about Attention Whoring and making the rest of the NORMAL people UNCOMFORTABLE as much as possible. If it was about Fair, those categories would have been stood up as soon as the first plastic surgery was completed, but they Weren’t. For the past 2 decades they’ve been intent on shoehorning the transgenders into pre-existing categories, refusing to acknowledge that they who self mutilate are no longer of either category they’re trying to be part of.
Its an interesting and eye opening reality. Its objective too. Next time you hear one, presuming ones unfortunate to be around such, point out the ease with which these disparities post mutilation can be addressed and watch them refuse them. Maybe they aren’t All like this, but from the medias representation of them, they sure seem to be.
The article continues:
“Advocates say the rhetoric surrounding these proposed bans further exacerbates an already treacherous environment for transgender people, their families and medical providers. Children’s hospitals around the country have faced an uptick of harassment and threats of violence for providing gender-confirming care.”
With more idle non-applicable commentary. The above pretends people are going around looking for Trans to bash. The reality is the trans are going around setting up Story hour to expose families Kids to their own confusion, and this opens the door for kids who have probably never bothered considering to wonder what sex they are, to start focusing on sex and their sexuality.
Hell with how often its in the news one can’t see how families kids can’t be exposed to such, specially with corporations like DISNEY putting GAY in every program.
You know why Childrens hospitals are getting threats for being willing to perform gender transition and reassignment surgeries, its because the kids being mismanaged by their parents and providers are being ruined before the choice is their Own to make. THIS should be prevented, as its one thing to see adults go do this to themselves as something they chose, with consequences they desired, but Kids aren’t given the choice, their parent or guardian has to hopefully be sane to prevent such from happening until the kids old enough to understand the consequences and Choose for themselves. Thats the RIGHT way to approach this where we make sure the kids are protected till they reach adulthood and then they can enjoy whatever consequences their actions produce, because it was THEIR choice.
The article goes on:
“People opposed to gender-affirming care for minors argue that children are too young to make decisions about their futures, sometimes comparing such treatments to child abuse. That’s despite medical experts saying the care is safe when administered properly.”
This is a heinous treatment of the public by pretending “medical experts” say the care is safe when “administered properly”. This is a two fer.
The medical experts are always unnamed. Pressing for names and you get other statements like “multiple sources agree” while never citing those sources. You find a single Medical Expert who will put their name behind this and you will see the focus of the Sane Hetero population descend upon those “experts” to make them repeal their “expert” status while also making said Expert elaborate on what “administered properly” means in plain objective terms. Guaranteed any expert willing to be named will not be willing to go into the details of their work.
As for child abuse, I mean its pretty simple to tell if its Child Abuse, tho it may take years for the one forcibly transitioned to come to such a conclusion if the decision wasn’t their own to make.
They try and shore up their Pro argument thusly:
“Nearly every major medical group, including the American Medical Association, has opposed the bans on such care for minors.”
And what that should tell you is that Every Major Medical Group is Compromised and pushing some other Agenda than the “Do No Harm” care that they pretended to stand and take an oath to do. Thus do not defer to their AUTHORITY.
All that noted, nobody seems to think of the Bigger picture and what it means when enough people self mutilate and end up sterilized, tho frankly thats probably a blessing in disguise, as nobody asks what happens when all sex is for pleasure and none of it is for generating families? Populations plummet.
Just to be Clear, if you want to Be Gay, by all means be Gay. But don’t self mutilate to ruin the form Nature seeded you in. Also enough with the I’m Gay and that means I have Merit false equivalence. You can be gay and be a moron too. The in your faceness of the gay crowd needs to simmer down, as I don’t ever recall parades of hetero out there putting that in everyones faces or I think I’d get sick of hearing about that too. It is just what is. It does not need EVERYONE to know about it or go along with it. It should be enough that one does what they want to do in their own privacy of their own home.
Course I suppose they already accounted for that with their Artificial womb labs and clone production facilities huh. That way there will be no Parents whose views have to be sidelined and supplanted with the views of the STATE as the only views worthy of ones thinking.
They would need those things in place so they can produce their offset population of indoctrinated lab grown clones while the Nature produced population is taken down thru “vaccines that depopulate via acute and chronic disease induction”. Course it seems they can make due with the illegals being induced to invade the USA while the obedient wait for their event to end their iteration of form.
Clone Links:
https://realrawnews.com/?s=clone
Artificial Womb Links:
https://jme.bmj.com/content/44/11/751
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7216961/
https://www.bbc.com/news/av/health-50056405
https://geneticliteracyproject.org/2022/04/22/artificial-wombs-the-coming-era-of-motherless-births/